Umsatzsteuer Newsletter

Search

The Federal Fiscal Court has expressed serious doubts about the lawfulness of the apportionment requirement for supplies of accommodation services. In justification, it refers to the ECJ submission of the V. Senate of the Federal Fiscal Court on the apportionment requirement for operating equipment. The decision on the suspension of execution thus brings fresh impetus to the discussion sparked by the ECJ judgment in the Stadion Amsterdam CV case as to whether the apportionment requirement for accommodation services is in conformity with EU law.
mehr
In the previous view of the German tax authorities, the VAT exemption for intra-Community supplies was to be dependent on the relevant EC Sales List being submitted or corrected in due time. Since the time this requirement was included in the German Administrative Circular in 2020, considerable doubt has existed as to whether this extremely strict view was actually acceptable under EU law. For some time now, there have been increasing loud whispers that the Federal Ministry of Finance would ultimately correct this. Now the time has finally come. In its letter of 20 May 2022, the Ministry clarifies that the VAT exemption cannot be denied solely on the basis of a failure to meet the deadline for the ECSL.
mehr
In its decision of 21 April 2022, the Federal Fiscal Court abandoned its previous generous case law on supplies in the sports sector. The national VAT exemption rule was classified as basically in conformity with EU law. The ruling also makes it clear that Union law allows the German legislator to exercise a quite generous scope of discretion. However, as long as the legislator does not make use of its possibilities in favour of sports clubs, taxable persons in the sports sector can no longer invoke Union law.
mehr

Pages