In fact, the case concerning in-app purchases appeared to have been settled by the ECJ’s preliminary ruling in the Xyrality case. However, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has now not ruled out the possibility that the app developer is liable for VAT, as the app store issued order confirmations in the developer’s name, and has referred the case back to the fiscal court for further clarification of the facts. So then, it is clear that the final word on this matter has not yet been spoken.